“I can’t write!” How many times have you heard one of your middle-schoolers declare defeat before they even begin to brainstorm for a writing assignment? Writing motivation declines in middle school, and there could be various reasons why, including social and developmental milestones and an emphasis on high-stakes testing.
No matter the reason, the priority is to reverse the trend. How can we get kids to put down the defeatist mentality and pick up the pencil? I believe it starts with boosting their motivation to write.
Why Writing Motivation Declines In Middle School
High-Stakes Testing: What Role Does It Play?
No matter where you stand on the issue of high-stakes testing, it’s clear it has an impact on students. You’ve seen the look on their faces when they come back to the classroom after a grueling assessment. It’s a lot of pressure and it takes a toll.
Beyond the anecdotal evidence is some concrete research we can hang our hats on: 7th graders who had just completed a round of standardized writing assessments reported less writing motivation compared to both 6th graders and 8th graders. We can only speculate, but when we think about the formulaic nature of standardized prompts and the pressure of getting it “right,” we may start to form our own ideas about exactly what demotivates young writers.
Are Social And Developmental Milestones Contributing Factors?
Testing aside, adolescence brings its own set of crises. Middle school students are in the throes of figuring out who they are, where they fit in, and how they choose to express themselves. These social and developmental questions may affect a young teen’s approach to writing assignments.

For example, if it’s a personal essay, it may leave them feeling vulnerable and exposed. On the other hand, an expository piece might feel irrelevant or too prescribed. Worse, their struggles with either assignment can chip away at their self-confidence, leaving them to label themselves as a “bad writer.” This label can be particularly problematic. Student’s perception of their writing ability is closely linked to their motivation to write.
Engaging Middle School Writers: How Can We Meet Them Where They Are?
Giving Autonomy And Choice
Middle-schoolers are actively seeking independence, yet they still need guidance. Too much structure may feel claustrophobic while the absence of guardrails can feel intimidating. If teachers are to meet them where they are, we need to provide choice within boundaries. In writing class, this might look like several writing prompts that achieve similar instructional goals.
Importance and Examples
In recent study, Brown followed seventh-grade writers who were granted broad liberties within a class writing assignment. Specifically, they were given autonomy when it came to choosing both genre and topic. Post-writing, students felt more empowered by their newfound freedoms and said their self-perceptions as writers were also improved.
To make these findings work for your own classroom, consider giving students the choice of audience, topic, and/or genre for their next writing assignment. For example, you could start with an overarching assignment: Write a persuasive text. Within this framework, allow students to choose:
- Their position
- Who they’re persuading
- The format of the text: persuasive letter, essay, or speech
Fostering Collaboration
Developmentally, middle school students prioritize social connections. While they might fear judgment when reading their essay aloud in front of class, they may simultaneously yearn for a lower-stakes opportunity to connect with their peers. This is where writing collaboration comes in. Not only can it create motivation for student writers, but dialed-in, it can also support instructional goals. And bonus, it’s evidence-based. Myhill’s study found that students responded positively to a more collaborative writing environment.
Collaborative Lesson Plan Ideas
Like the writing assignment mentioned above, try focusing on freedom within structure for your collaborative lesson plans. For example, you can hold peer brainstorming groups that allow students to freely express ideas. Add scaffolding by giving them a list of “buzzwords” to consider during their session. Then, model a position statement that you created using two of the words provided. The sample list below can be adapted to different assignments and stages of the writing process.
Buzzwords for Brainstorming
- Liberty
- Protection
- Abuse
- Power
- Limits
- Rights
- Justice
- Social media
- Economy
- Speech
- Restrictions

Allot each group a certain amount of time (say, 10 to 20 minutes). Then, ask them to come up with a debatable position or thesis statement plus two supporting points. The end result might look something like the following:
Position/Thesis Statement: Freedom of speech should be restricted on social media to protect people’s privacy.
Supporting Point 1: People’s reputations are routinely damaged on social media due to baseless claims.
Supporting Point 2: Social media companies make enough money to provide preventative oversight.
This task combines elements of autonomy and collaboration with enough structure to ensure a productive session.
What Does Unstructured Writing Look Like?
While middle-schoolers may benefit from the structure of scaffolding to build writing skills, they might also appreciate the opportunity to express themselves freely. Reminding students that writing isn’t for the sole purpose of passing a test or earning a score can make a difference.
Give your budding writers the opportunity to experience the joy of writing minus the fear of evaluation. Whether you use this exercise as a lesson opener or full-fledged assignment, students may appreciate the opportunity to write for the sake of writing.
Early in my career as a writing teacher, I opened each lesson with a brief free-writing exercise. I was convinced my students wouldn’t do anything if they weren’t being graded for it. So, I encouraged free-writing, but I still had students turn their papers in at the end of the writing period. It didn’t take me long to realize my efforts had backfired. As I read their responses, I noticed they lacked an authentic voice. I felt that students were simply writing what they thought I wanted to read.
I started letting the kids keep their writing and gave them the opportunity to share their responses verbally. Immediately, the room felt different. My impression? The kids were truly expressing themselves, not just checking off another grade earned. Many were eager to read their writing aloud, and we had many animated discussions. Not everyone shared, of course, but the choice to decline played its own role in encouraging students to write what they really thought, not what they thought I wanted from them.
Sample Unstructured Writing Prompts
Here are some ideas for unstructured writing prompts you can use in class:
- Write about a dream you’ve had or someone else had.
- Write advice to your 3rd-grade self.
- Write about something you care about.
- Write about something you’re afraid of.
- What’s something that recently surprised you?
When giving these prompts, make sure students know that their responses won’t be graded. You could go one step further and assure them that their responses are for their eyes only if you wish. Ask students to temporarily forget about all the rules you’ve taught them and simply focus on their thoughts and ideas.
How Can We Measure Progress?
When writing teachers think of measuring progress, we tend to think of rubrics. However, measuring motivation may require a different approach. Other ways to assess progress may include informal observations, student surveys, and finished product evaluations. Look for subtle changes in your students’ attitudes and behaviors. Note whether they’re:
- Starting on assignments more quickly
- Complaining less about assignments
- Experiencing more “flow” as opposed to starting and stopping
For a more structured progress report, you could have students complete a short survey before and after each writing assignment. Ask them to agree or disagree with statements like:
- I feel confident in my writing.
- I’m generally a skilled writer.
- I care about the things I write about for this class.
- I enjoy the process of writing.
- I find it difficult to begin writing.
- I start and stop writing multiple times because I run out of ideas.
- The writing prompts are interesting.
- I enjoy being able to choose my own topic.
How Do We Help Writers Maintain Enthusiasm Over Time?
Motivating middle-schoolers to write is an ambitious, yet achievable goal. It will likely take more than one fun collaborative lesson plan or free-writing prompt to accomplish. However, as you begin to implement these ideas, consider them a long-term strategy rather than a one-off. Better yet, use them as a launching pad for your own ideas and lesson plans.
Here are some actionable steps you can take to keep the momentum going:
- Have students evaluate their own work and choose selected pieces to showcase in a portfolio. Ask them to write one sentence explaining the rationale behind each selection.
- Assign certain activities for certain days to create a reliable routine. For example, consider free-writing Fridays or peer-revision sessions every other Tuesday.
- After each writing assignment, read various essays aloud (with permission) and talk about their strengths and areas for improvement.
- For students who would rather not read aloud, try a writing game. Story Writing Lab runs short timed rounds with prompts made for middle schoolers, and classmates vote anonymously, so everyone gets an audience without the spotlight.
Try one of the lesson strategies above in your classroom next week. Measure your progress and use the results to plan your next motivational lesson plan!



